Read e-book online Arabic logic: Ibn al-Ṭayyib's commentary on Porphyry's PDF

By Kwame Gyekye

ISBN-10: 0873953088

ISBN-13: 9780873953085

Show description

Read Online or Download Arabic logic: Ibn al-Ṭayyib's commentary on Porphyry's Eisagoge PDF

Best logic & language books

Robert H. Thouless, C.R. Thouless's Straight and Crooked Thinking (Headway Books) PDF

An advent to logical considering and the methods of argument, with 37 demonstrations of illogical and crooked pondering, and the way they are triumph over by way of directly notion.

Download e-book for iPad: Principle of Individuality and Value (Gifford Lectures) by Bernard Bosanquet

This can be a replica of a e-book released ahead of 1923. This booklet can have occasional imperfections akin to lacking or blurred pages, negative photographs, errant marks, and so on. that have been both a part of the unique artifact, or have been brought by means of the scanning strategy. We think this paintings is culturally vital, and regardless of the imperfections, have elected to convey it again into print as a part of our carrying on with dedication to the renovation of revealed works all over the world.

Extra info for Arabic logic: Ibn al-Ṭayyib's commentary on Porphyry's Eisagoge

Sample text

The study also takes into account the four extant Greek commentaries of Ammonius, Elias, Pseudo-Elias and David. Parallels between the commentaries of Ibn al-Tayyib and these Alexandrian scholars have been pointed out in the Commentary. I wish to thank the following scholars for the different kinds of assistance I received from them: the late Emeritus Prof. A. Wolfson; Prof. John E. Murdoch of the Department of the History of Science; Prof. L. Owen of the Department of Philosophy and Classics; Dr.

That is to say, he, unlike Ibn al-Tayyib, does not quote verbatim a passage from Porphyry's work and comment upon it. His "Eisagoge" is rather a restatement or paraphrase of the subject matter of Porphyry in his own way and with his own views on it. The views of the eminent philosopher, al-Farabi, have, where relevant, also been mentioned. Ibn al-Tayyib's own commentary on the Categories (as yet unpublished) has been referred to in a handful of places. The study also takes into account the four extant Greek commentaries of Ammonius, Elias, Pseudo-Elias and David.

Iii) Predication. The author emphasizes that individuals are the genuine subjects of predication. ) fail to see that Porphyry in his Eisagoge makes the individual a predicate. Ibn al-Tayyib, but not the Alexandrians, criticizes Porphyry for this, insisting that only concepts (or, what he calls "forms existing in the soul," al-suwar al-maujuda fi 'l-nafs), not individuals, can be predicates, a doctrine equally emphasized in modern logic (see para. 91, 92, 95, 96, 171-174 of text). In fact, by making the individual a predicate, Porphyry contradicted himself, for according to the Tree of Porphyry, (para.

Download PDF sample

Arabic logic: Ibn al-Ṭayyib's commentary on Porphyry's Eisagoge by Kwame Gyekye


by Daniel
4.3

Rated 4.84 of 5 – based on 29 votes